UNFCCC COP31: Worst Unfinished Business ENCORE

I HELD MY BREATH FOR SANITY TO PREVAIL

IT DIDN’T

The UN climate summit in Antalya, Türkiye (COP31) was scheduled to end Friday, November 20. It ran two extra days, and French media are calling it the longest COP in history. On Sunday, November 22, COP31 President Murat Kurum struck the gavel and announced that the main decision, the “Antalya Pact,” had not been adopted. Nearly 200 countries had failed to reach consensus.

What the first draft said (November 16)

My colleague Dr. Peter Carter of the Climate Emergency Institute went through the first draft line by line in his November 18 video (watch here). He singled out Paragraph 106 as “a mighty important statement on policy”:

106. Recognizes the leadership of Indigenous Peoples as stewards of nature and the important role of their knowledge, wisdom and values in effective action on climate change, including through the use of traditional knowledge and knowledge of indigenous peoples, where appropriate, emphasizes that climate action must respect, promote and fulfil the inherent and distinct rights of Indigenous Peoples, including their right to free, prior and informed consent, in accordance with the United Nations Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples, and urges Parties to actively involve Indigenous Peoples in the design and implementation of climate action, noting climate solutions must not come at the expense of the territories, practices, livelihoods, rights, and lives of these Indigenous Peoples.

“Free, prior and informed consent” is a simple idea: no project goes ahead on Indigenous land unless the people who live there agree to it, knowing the facts and without pressure. That includes mines for “clean energy” minerals.

How it unraveled

The revised draft of November 19 cut Paragraph 106. It never mentioned free, prior and informed consent, the UN Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples, or even the words “human rights.” It also dropped every mention of fossil fuels and the proposed $120 billion adaptation finance target, and it leaned heavily on carbon capture instead.

This image has an empty alt attribute; its file name is unpfii-2025.jpg
UN Photo/Manuel Elías | The 25th Session of the Permanent Forum on Indigenous Issues (UNPFII)

The European Union, Panama, the Marshall Islands and others refused to accept a deal that was silent on fossil fuels. In the end, no cover decision was adopted at all.

Where that leaves us

  • Separate decisions on just transition, climate finance and technology did pass.
  • The commitment from COP28 in Dubai to transition away from fossil fuels still stands. Antalya didn’t weaken it, but it didn’t build on it either.
  • No Antalya text on Indigenous Peoples’ rights exists, strong or weak. Paragraph 106 is unfinished business.

Blocking a weak deal was better than adopting one. But two weeks of talks produced no statement that climate action must respect the people who protect much of the world’s remaining forests and biodiversity, and whose lands hold the minerals the energy transition depends on.

The next chance is COP32 in Addis Ababa, Ethiopia, in 2027.

I am no longer holding my breath for sanity to prevail at COP


COP IS A LOST CAUSE IMHO

What is needed to replace COP is GETA


May sanity prevail with GETA


Thank you, Dr. Peter Carter 🙏

Unknown's avatar

About doug350

Go Slow Quickly. Srsly!
This entry was posted in Uncategorized. Bookmark the permalink.

Leave a Reply